The cafe serves Australian cuisine and offers vegetarian-friendly, vegan options, and gluten-free options. The atmosphere of the cafe is described as “spunky” and “scurvy”. Customers have praised the cafe for its amazing food, fast and friendly service, and great atmosphere. One of the standout features of Scallywags Cafe is its play area for children, which has been described as “awesome”. The cafe also serves remarkable fair trade coffee. Scallywags Cafe has a price range of $6 to $17. While there are other food options in Nelly Bay, Scallywags Cafe is highly rated and offers healthy options on the island. It is located in a convenient location and has a great atmosphere.